ASD ISM 1089 Block downgrading protective markings on email replies and forwards
What it says
When replying to or forwarding emails, protective marking tools do not allow the selection of protective markings lower than previously used.
Quoted as published. Everything else on this page is written by Control Stack.
In plain English
On replies and forwards, protective marking tools must not let users choose a lower marking than the email already carried.
When a user replies to or forwards an email, the protective marking tool must not let them select a protective marking lower than the one the email previously carried. A protective marking is the label showing an email's sensitivity or classification. The user may keep the same marking or choose a higher one. The rule covers reply, reply all and forward, in every email client the tool runs in. Under ISM-0271 the tool still must not insert the marking automatically.
Free. Save your status, tasks and notes.
Why it matters
Email filters may read only an email's latest marking, and a reply or forward marked lower than the original usually still carries the original's contents, so a filter could let it reach a system not authorised for them. Refusing lower markings closes that gap.
How to implement
Turn on the tool's rule against lowering markings.
Apply it to reply, reply all and forward, so the tool compares each choice with the marking on the email being answered and hides or refuses anything lower.
Make the tool read markings set elsewhere.
Configure it to recognise the marking on emails received from other organisations, so the rule still applies when another organisation's tool set the earlier marking.
Test every client and way of editing.
Try desktop, web and mobile clients, and try lowering the marking by editing the subject line or by removing and reselecting it. Where a client cannot enforce the rule, replace it or block it from sending email.
Keep it running
Retest replies and forwards in each client after any update to the tool or email client, and before allowing a new client, because either can lose track of the earlier marking.
Evidence and audit
- Check 1 of 2What an auditor asks for
Ask for
A demonstration, in each email client seen in sign-in records, of replying to and forwarding test emails marked at each level the system handles, including emails received from another organisation.
Look at
Which markings the tool offers and accepts on reply, reply all and forward, including after editing the subject line.
Good evidence
No client offers or accepts a marking lower than the test email's own on reply, reply all or forward, including by editing the subject line.
- Check 2 of 2What an auditor asks for
Ask for
A sample of marked email threads from the mail archive or users' mailboxes, including emails received from other organisations.
Look at
Whether any reply or forward is marked lower than the email it answers.
Good evidence
No reply or forward in the sampled threads carries a marking lower than the email it replied to or forwarded.
Mappings
Closest match in ISO/IEC 27001: A.5.12, Classification of information, which this control partially meets.
ISO/IEC 27001: 3 mappings
This control partially meets A.5.12.
ISM-1089 requires enforcement to stop downgrading of protective markings on email replies and forwards. ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A 5.12 requires the organisation to classify information according to business and security needs, which drives what markings should be used and when. ISM-1089 implements a concrete safeguard to uphold that classification policy in email workflows, but Annex A 5.12 covers the wider governance of classification decisions beyond email tooling.
This control partially meets A.5.13.
ISM-1089 requires email protective marking tools to prevent users from selecting a lower protective marking when replying to or forwarding an email. ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A 5.13 requires procedures for information labelling aligned to the organisation's classification scheme, which includes ensuring labels/markings are applied correctly in communications. ISM-1089 is a specific technical enforcement mechanism for one labelling scenario (email reply/forward), whereas Annex A 5.13 is broader and covers labelling procedures across information types and channels.
This control supports A.8.12.
ISM-1089 requires email tooling to prevent users from lowering protective markings during reply/forward, reducing the chance of mislabelling sensitive content. ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Annex A 8.12 requires data leakage prevention measures across systems that process, store or transmit sensitive information, which commonly includes email DLP policies. ISM-1089 supports Annex A 8.12 by preserving correct classification/marking signals that DLP and handling rules can act on, but it does not itself constitute comprehensive DLP across channels and content types.
Mappings show how controls relate across frameworks. They do not imply full equivalence or certification.




