Skip to content
Communications systems
ASD ISMISM-0231

ASD ISM 0231 Visual indication for secure telephone connections

What it says

When using cryptographic equipment to permit different levels of conversation for different kinds of connections, telephone systems give a visual indication of what kind of connection has been made.

Quoted as published. Everything else on this page is written by Control Stack.

In plain English

Where cryptographic equipment allows different levels of conversation on different kinds of connection, telephone systems must visually show which kind of connection has been made.

Where cryptographic equipment lets different kinds of connection, such as encrypted calls and on-site calls, carry different levels of conversation, the telephone system must show visually which kind of connection has been made. Cryptographic equipment is hardware that encrypts the call. The indication has to reflect the connection actually made, not the number dialled or the level expected, and the user must be able to see it. Telephone systems that do not use cryptographic equipment this way fall outside this control. ISM-0229 covers telling personnel what may be discussed.

Why it matters

When one phone can carry different levels of conversation, the person speaking cannot tell by listening which connection they have. A visual indication shows the kind of connection before they speak, which reduces the chance of saying more than that connection permits.

How to implement

  1. List telephone systems where cryptographic equipment sets the conversation level.

    Include any system whose cryptographic equipment permits some kinds of connection a different level of conversation from others. For each, write down every kind of connection and its permitted level. If no system works this way, record that, so the control can be shown not to apply.

  2. Assign one visual indication to each kind of connection.

    Use the phone's display text, an indicator light, or the cryptographic equipment's own display if the user can see it. A fixed label does not work, because it cannot change with the connection. Add what each indication means to the advice ISM-0229 requires.

  3. Drive the indication from the connection actually made.

    Take it from the cryptographic equipment or call controller, not the number dialled, so a call that connects differently shows as what it is. Where a product cannot do this, replace it or run all connections at one level, so the condition no longer applies.

  4. Test every kind of connection on each handset model.

    Place calls of each kind, including one where the expected path is unavailable, and record what the phone shows. Keep the results to compare against after later changes.

Keep it running

Retest each kind of connection when cryptographic equipment, telephone firmware, handset models or call routing change, because any of these can break the link between the connection and what the phone shows.

Evidence and audit

  1. Check 1 of 3What an auditor asks for

    Ask for

    The list of telephone systems using cryptographic equipment to permit different levels of conversation, with network diagrams and equipment records to compare it with.

    Look at

    Whether every telephone system connected to cryptographic equipment is either on the list or shown not to permit different levels of conversation, and whether each kind of connection is listed with its indication.

    Good evidence

    Every telephone system connected to cryptographic equipment in the diagrams or equipment records is either on the list or shown not to permit different levels of conversation, and each listed system has an indication defined for every kind of connection.

  2. Check 2 of 3What an auditor asks for

    Ask for

    Live test calls of each kind of connection from a sample of handsets, chosen on a walk-through of the areas using those systems.

    Look at

    What each phone shows once the connection is made, and whether the user can see it.

    Good evidence

    Each kind of connection gives its own visual indication on every sampled handset, the user can see it, and it matches the connection actually made.

  3. Check 3 of 3What an auditor asks for

    Ask for

    A test call with the expected path unavailable, run in a test environment or under change control.

    Look at

    Whether the indication shows the connection actually made, or the call fails to connect.

    Good evidence

    The phone shows the kind of connection actually made, or the call does not connect, and it never shows the indication for a different kind of connection. On a system used for sensitive or classified conversations, an unencrypted connection over an external system still fails ISM-0232.

Mappings

Closest match in ISO/IEC 27001: A.5.14, Information transfer, which this control partially meets.

ISO 27001

ISO/IEC 27001: 1 mapping

  • A.5.14Information transferPartially meets

Mappings show how controls relate across frameworks. They do not imply full equivalence or certification.